FootyChatter.com

By Joe Bernstein Published: 02: 57 AEDT, 27 October 2024 | Updated: 04: 31 AEDT, 27 October 2024 41 View comments Top beat bottom as expected but not in the straightforward manner anticipated. In fact, struggling Southampton took more positives in defeat than champions Manchester City did by collecting the points. When Erling Haaland scored after five minutes – a more orthodox finish than his astounding kung-fu volley in midweek – an expectant Etihad waited for the floodgates to open. It never happened because Saints performed far better than their league position suggested and hit the crossbar through Cameron Archer. Even the trophy-laden Pep Guardiola viewed it as an education as Russell Martin’s players showed courage trying to play their football in one of the game’s toughest environments ‘I am going to learn a lot with Russell because they did really well, ’ said the respectful City boss. Erling Haaland took his Premier League tally this season to 11 with an acrobatic effort early on Haaland contorted his body to meet Matheus Nunes' cross to earn three points for Man City Pep Guardiola's claimed he could learn from Southampton boss Russell Martin post match ‘If they had possession (50% in the first half), it was not because we were bad – it was because they were good. They opened the channels and their build-up was excellent. ‘Maybe in the future I can use it. I have learned a lot in my career from opposing managers. ’ Man City (4-3-3):  Ederson 6: Lewis 6 (Stones 90), Akanji 6. 5, Dias 6. 5, Gvardiol 8; Kovacic 6. 5, Bernardo 7, Foden 6; Savinho 7. 5, Haaland 6. 5, Nunes 6 (Gundogan 87) Subs unused: Ortega (Gk), Carson (Gk), Ake, O’Reilly, Mc Atee Booked: Kovacic  Goal: Haaland 5 Manager: Pep Guardiola 7 Southampton (5-4-1):  Ramsdale 7: Walker-Peters 6, Bednarek 5. 5, Stephens 6. 5, Harwood-Bellis 7, Manning 7 (Bree 76); Dibling 5. 5 (Armstrong 45 6. 5), Fernandes 6, Downes 6. 5 (Sulemana 87), Lallana 6. 5 (Aribo 60 6. 5); Archer 6 (Onuachu 87) Subs unused: Mc Carthy (Gk), Aribo, Armstrong, Bree, Sugawara, Cornet, Ugochukwu Booked: Downes, Armstrong, Lallana Manager: Russell Martin 7 Referee: Tony Harrington 5. 5 For Martin, a near-miss at The Etihad is justification of his methods which have been criticised as naïve during a winless start to the campaign ‘Pep congratulated us afterwards on the way we play. It is not easy and he probably understands that more than anyone, ’ he said. ‘We played with extreme courage and if the players can do that here, they can do it anywhere. I am going to live or die by the sword of what I believe in. ’ It should be pointed out City did get over the line and remain unbeaten at home since November 2022 – when Lionel Messi hadn’t won a World Cup. They leapfrogged Liverpool and will stay in pole position unless Arne Slot’s side win at Arsenal on Sunday. A late equaliser by Wolves at Brighton left Saints rock-bottom and the upbeat slant on their showing will appear hollow unless they beat Everton next weekend to give themselves a chance of survival. Their No1 Aaron Ramsdale was the busier goalkeeper and, on another day, Haaland could have added another hat-trick match ball to his collection. But given the doom-mongers that predicted a City romp, Southampton did create danger. Besides Archer’s one-on-one, only a hacked clearance by Manuel Akanji then prevented substitute Paul Onuachu levelling with a header in second-half injury-time. It was testimony to City’s discomfort that an extra centre-half, John Stones, was sent on in the final minute to ensure the points were secured. Guardiola only named five outfield substitutes because of a lengthy injury list that included Kevin De Bruyne, Jack Grealish and Jeremy Doku. Their fast start was rewarded when Matheus Nunes whipped in a cross from the left and Haaland ignore the attentions of Jan Bednarek to reach the ball with his left foot whilst toppling backwards. Nunes assisted Haaland's winner in a good performance on a first league start of the campaign Haaland should have added to his tally but missed a series of presentable opportunities The forward shot wide from close range when he seemed poised to score a second goal City wingers Savinho and Nunes caused Southampton’s back-five problems on either flank but the patience of the visitors playing through the lines almost paid dividends when wing-back Ryan Manning galloped into acres of space and his cross had to be dealt with by the excellent Josko Gvardiol. At the start of the second half, Phil Foden shot wide and Haaland was denied by a goal-line clearance from Taylor Harwood-Bellis and then couldn’t convert a Savinho cross from a few yards. The pesky visitors couldn’t be put away and Saints also felt they had a rough time from referee Tony Harrington, who penalised Flynn Downes and then booked him for a great tackle on Bernardo Silva. Manager Martin was also cautioned. ‘I am annoyed about that. All I did was throw my arms up in the air, ’ complained the Saints boss who will serve a touchline ban in the Carabao Cup this week. Half-time Saints substitute Adam Armstrong ran the channels tirelessly and tested Ederson. Centre-forward Paul Onuachu came on for a final charge and worried City with his power in the air. Southampton's Cameron Archer struck the crossbar in the visitors best chance of the match Russell Martin's side are now bottom, with other results going against them after their defeat Martin expressed pride in his side with Paul Onuachu seeing a late effort cleared by Man City I’m proud of them, ’ Martin said about his players. We had more [chances] than most I think coming here. It wasn’t just defensive. We were brilliant with the ball. ’ Guardiola’s attention will now turn to watching rivals Arsenal and Liverpool battle it out on Sunday. ‘I will watch it, ’ he confirmed. ‘I prefer to be top than not top! This was such a demanding game for us. You can see how difficult the Premier League is. Aston Villa dropped points. Brighton dropped points. ’ City were relieved just to get over the line. Their narrow wins against lowly Wolves and Southampton might make all the difference next May. Published by Associated Newspapers Ltd Part of the Daily Mail, The Mail on Sunday & Metro Media Group